Oakland’s City Council voted unanimously on Tuesday to extend their initial 45-day data center moratorium until next October. It was a victory for the residents engaged in an opposition fight since August.
The new proposal by the Behring Company would transform a former supercomputing complex into an “AI campus” that would include a 20,000 square-foot data center. It would be situated downtown, on the same block as the 19th street BART station.
Oakland currently has one functioning data center: a four-story, 122,000 square-foot building near Jack London Square, operated by Digital Reality and housing over a dozen internet providers.
Oakland is a historic industrial town. The factories developed in the mid-to-late 19th century facilitated the population boom and transformed Oakland into a major city. It’s also a history that illustrates the extractive nature of industrialization. For one, the long-term impacts of air pollution from the Port of Oakland and surrounding infrastructure has disproportionately increased the risk of health issues in west Oakland residents. Cancer, heart disease, stroke, respiratory diseases, and asthma rates are all higher than average. The life expectancy in west Oakland is, on average, seven years lower than the wider Alameda county average.
Colin Behring, CEO of the Behring Company, said in a press conference that nothing notable will change when the building becomes a data center. He blamed the prominence of data centers in the news cycle for an implied misunderstanding among Oakland residents of how this building would affect them; that it wouldn’t be a data center on a massive scale, and would be mostly used to run the rest of the AI campus proposed to surround it.
Behring Companies are headquartered further east in Danville, one of the richest cities in the country. A 2022 40 Under 40 profile of Colin Behring says he does not reside in Oakland, but in Blackhawk.
Actual residents of Oakland showed up to Tuesday’s city council meeting with final comments before the moratorium extension vote. Only a couple of speakers in a long slate were against the moratorium. A handful of advocacy and organizing groups spoke together. Many individuals identified themselves as longtime, even multi-generational, residents. I want to share some of their closing arguments with you. The work of Oakland residents and organizers, some of whom spoke at Tuesday’s meeting, highlights broader concerns shared by communities wherever data centers are proposed. They also highlight the specific significance of big tech moving into Oakland, given its proximity to Silicon Valley and San Francisco, and its history of redlining, discriminatory housing practices, and environmental racism.
One week to the day after the midterm elections, one speaker referenced their results and the nationwide, bipartisan anti-data-center sentiment.
“Don’t cast your vote today based on the illusion we’re operating on the old economy, where corporate investment in Oakland meant thousands of lasting good paying jobs, as well as property, business, and income tax flowing into city coffers,” she said. “In this new economy, where every investment is just another asset to be exploited and used as collateral for more investment, every corporate move is to extract from our communities. That’s what data centers will mean for Oakland.”
“Why don’t you have it over in your area, instead of my area, which is west Oakland? I’m tired of them doing stuff to us,” another lifelong resident said. “I’m not getting generational wealth from a data center… They’re not giving us community benefits, none whatsoever.”
A young activist and east Oakland organizer with Communities for a Better Environment spoke on behalf of their local membership’s vehement opposition to the data center: “We know that if we allow it, it will go straight to east Oakland, which already has so much industry, so much pollution,” she said. “Oakland is historically redlined and gentrified, with deliberate disinvestments by our government, so I just urge you to vote yes today.”
Organizers from Care 4 Community, a local 501(c)(4) pursuing an increase of democratic participation in Oakland’s community, spoke in a group. They’d knocked on over 2,400 doors in west Oakland, spoken with residents, and conducted 424 surveys collecting opinions about the data center and a moratorium. Their surveys showed 73% of residents support a permanent ban on all AI data centers in Oakland. Only 2% of residents surveyed opposed an outright data center ban. “We aren’t speaking on assumptions,” one member said. “We’re bringing the voices and concerns of the people directly to this council. Extending this moratorium is not just an ask, it’s a need, and it’s a request coming directly from the residents of west Oakland… We need to do more homework and that homework requires more time.” There was applause in the chamber after she spoke.
“I want you to understand something,” a second C4C member continued, addressing the council. “We didn’t just hear people’s concerns, we saw the worry and frustrations on their faces. People are worried about their electricity bills going up, they’re worried about rent continuing to rise, they’re worried about being pushed out of neighborhoods they’ve called home for generations.”
From a local Baptist minister and resident of west Oakland: “I want to extend the context here. Data centers are a part of the necessary infrastructure for the rise of an economically and politically untouchable class. And people are not just being luddites, displaying an irrational fear of technology. Technological innovation is not equivalent to social progress. The steam engine was a technological innovation, but it led to Indian removal in the name of westward expansion. The cotton gin was a technological innovation, but it fueled African enslavement. Technologies are released into societies and cultures in ways that create winners and losers. Technological advance is not the problem in and of itself, but it’s the people who control it. Corporate actors continually find that the straightest line to profitability is to sever any sense of moral obligation to one’s fellow human being in a quest for another dollar. And it leaves vulnerable communities open to being thrown under the bus.”
A representative from the Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE): “As you can see in this room, there’s a lot of melanated faces. What I’m telling you now is that this has started in 1619 and has not abated since. The billionaires aren’t in the room. This is classism. We’re not talking about proposing a data center over there in Marin County on Skywalker Ranch, we’re proposing it in Oakland. This is where the poor people are, the wealthy people aren’t here. This is part of a design to disenfranchise us, again. Let’s be real about this. We don’t need a data center in Oakland. Do not do this. It affects our price, our way of living, and we can barely afford living as it is in this city.”
An organizer from the local chapter of the Party for Socialism and Liberation:
“As others have said, the problem is not the technological innovation. The problem is technology that’s in the wrong hands, and right now, it’s very clear that AI technology is in the wrong hands. This weekend, on Saturday, ICE kidnapped four people from Oakland in four separate operations, and yesterday, ICE was spotted in the vicinity of three different Oakland schools. ICE uses AI data centers to process the information it needs to stalk and abduct immigrant communities. So it’s clear that billionaires and corporations are in the driver’s seat right now with AI technology, and they are motivated only by profit. Their values do not align with the people of Oakland.”
“I’ve lived in east, north, and west Oakland, so I am concerned for all of Oakland,” a lifelong resident concluded. “Let’s bring some productive businesses to Oakland, that actually help Oaklanders, who improve the health of Oaklanders, not kill us. These centers are killers. Let’s protect Oaklanders. If you love this city like you say you do, if you love your constituents like you say you do, extend this moratorium, and then in ten months, come back and say no to AI.”
Oakland City Council voted on the moratorium extension minutes later. The chamber cheered loudly when it passed unopposed.
A moratorium on data centers is undeniably a win. However, it doesn’t explicitly prevent two other developments in progress in west Oakland by Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk. Prometheus, Bezos’s understated AI startup, signed a lease at the former site of the American Steel complex. More on that Wednesday.
There’s a sentiment that seems to follow data center development, usually purported by the developers. Proposing data centers on land already zoned for and with a history of industrial use is a no-brainer for developers who don’t live in that area. It’s posed as reindustrialization that will invigorate the local economy, while usually not expanding or providing details of how many jobs will be local or permanent. And, from Wisconsin Rapids to Oakland, just because land has an industrial history doesn’t mean data centers will be welcomed uncritically by a community that has to live with the long term visceral health effects.



