Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nathan Wallner's avatar

"We sacrifice our right to be arbiters of our own experiences."

Brilliant! Great article, and your diagnosis is absolutely correct.

The issue with AI is that it treats the end goal as the only thing that matters.

'Booking a trip? Why go through all the MENIAL LABOR or actually looking for a hotel or planning the route? Just outsource it to an AI!'

We're outsourcing the very thing that makes us human, i.e. our ability to MAKE DECISIONS and REASON.

If we ever DO get to UBI, what are people going to do? Wake up and ask 'Hey Claude, what should I do today?'

Is THAT the future of humanity?

We're already outsourcing most of our free time to mind-numbing algorithms that waste our lives. Now the only meaningful decisions we get to make are ALSO going to be outsourced?

Then we're not living beings anymore. We're the VESSELS, and the AIs are the beings.

Ralph Haygood's avatar

"'It's easiest to literally pretend you have a superhuman person with a phone, a computer, an email address, who can call you - like you're dealing with a person, and that's it,' CEO Noah Shinn explained, shortly after his company was valued at $10 billion one month after launch.":

Evidently, many rich people believe such infantile surrender of agency is or should be the future of humanity en masse. That says a lot about them, none of it flattering. In general, such people are long on arrogance and short on empathy*, so it's unsurprising they prefer interacting with sycophantic simulacra of people rather than actual people. However, they're trying to make that the norm for everyone else too.

An appropriate question is, how long are the rest of us going to put up with such pernicious folly? More specifically, how long are we going to pretend such people aren't mentally defective or ill in ways that should disqualify them from having any power over other people, let alone the outrageously disproportionate influence they currently exert on politics and government? In plain view, they're driving civilization toward collapse, with "AI", climate change, and much else. They surely won't stop of their own accord.

*Headline at The Guardian today: "Why Arturo Béjar left Meta - and blew the whistle: 'I don't recall Mark ever being empathetic'" (https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/08/arturo-bejar-interview-whistleblower-facebook-meta-mark-zuckerberg)

Ready for more?